Not in my backyard

They call it "NIMBY," an appropriate acronym that stands for "not in my backyard." It is used most often by people that tell you about all the things they support as long as those things aren't in their neighborhood.

We saw "NIMBY" at work full time Wednesday in the cramped hearing room of the regional Virginia Alcohol Beverage Control Board regional office on Peters Creek Road in Floyd County as a few residents of Thomas Farm Road near the Blue Ridge Parkway tried to tell the rest of us that the last thing we need is a small, family-owned microbrewery around here.

They were joined by a Baptist preacher from Check who offered dire predictions of drunks tear-assing up and down the narrow gravel road that leads to and from the proposed Shooting Creek Farm Brewery. Of course, the Rev. Warren Brown didn't bother to say how folks who visit a brewery that doesn't serve beer on premises are going to get blasted. Maybe they were going to buy a six-pack, stop just off the driveway, guzzle all six bottles, and then terrorize the locals.

The 30 or so county residents who crammed into the hearing room for the three-and-a-half hour hearing heard a lot of emotional talk from four residents of Thomas Farm Road who vehemently oppose the effort. The owners of the proposed micro brewery have a petition of seven other residents who say they support the effort. That pretty much accounts for the 11 occupied homes along the two-and-a-half mile stretch of road.

Thomas Farm Road resident Jean Lacoste broke down and cried, saying the brewery right across the road from their home is destroying the life they hoped to make on Thomas Farm Road. Her husband, Paul, second-guessed county officials who approved the operation and suggested the brewery owners didn't have the proper permits to operate the facility. Others talked about traffic "doubling" on the road. The owners estimate about 10 visitors a day on the four days a week (Thursday through Sunday) when they plan to be open. A Virginia Department of Transportation study found about 15 vehicles a day travel the road now and that includes cars, FedEx/UPI delivery van and logging trucks.

Brett Nichols, one of the four owners of the proposed operation, calls Shooting Creek Farm Brewery a "small, family-run operation." Nichols is already operating an organic farm at the location and says he feels the operation will increase the property values of the owners, who also live on Thomas Farm Road. Opponents disagree, saying the brewery will dump their property values into the crapper.

We don't have a brewery in our neighborhood. The folks who own the farm across Sandy Flats Road from our property own race cars and sometimes tune them late into the night. Their kids own dirt bikes and like to race up and down the hills of the farm. Sometimes the race cars and dirt bikes are loud but it's their property and the Floyd County way is to let people make their own decision about how to use their land.

Hearing officer Robert O'Neal said he will deliver an opinion on the license for the brewery in 30-45 days but the neighborhood feud is not likely to end with that decision. The losing side can appeal for a rehearing before the state board officers in Richmond, a process that will extend the fight for two-to-three months more. Then whichever size loses can appeal again for a hearing before Judge Ray W. Grubbs in Floyd County Circuit Court -- which means the fight will drag on until next year.

But O'Neal put the whole battle into perspective when he asked Nichols how much beer his operation would brew in a year. The answer: About 600 barrels.  About half of that will go into kegs to wholesale distribution to bars and restaurants in and around Floyd County. The other half will be bottled and packed into 360 cases.

O'Neal wanted to know how much room it takes to store or ship 360 cases of beer. Nichols said it would take three 4x4 palletes (each pallete holds 80 cases).

O'Neal calculated the volume of both the cases and kegs and noted that the entire annual production of the proposed micro brewery would not fill half of a single trailor on a semi-truck.

"In other words, we're not talking about Budweiser here," he said.

Nope. We're not.

They call it "NIMBY," an appropriate acronym that stands for "not in my backyard." It is used most often by people that tell you about all the things they support as long as those things aren’t in their neighborhood.

We saw "NIMBY" at work full time Wednesday in the cramped hearing room of the regional Virginia Alcohol Beverage Control Board regional office on Peters Creek Road in Floyd County as a few residents of Thomas Farm Road near the Blue Ridge Parkway tried to tell the rest of us that the last thing we need is a small, family-owned microbrewery around here.

They were joined by a Baptist preacher from Check who offered dire predictions of drunks tear-assing up and down the narrow gravel road that leads to and from the proposed Shooting Creek Farm Brewery. Of course, the Rev. Warren Brown didn’t bother to say how folks who visit a brewery that doesn’t serve beer on premises are going to get blasted. Maybe they were going to buy a six-pack, stop just off the driveway, guzzle all six bottles, and then terrorize the locals.

The 30 or so county residents who crammed into the hearing room for the three-and-a-half hour hearing heard a lot of emotional talk from four residents of Thomas Farm Road who vehemently oppose the effort. The owners of the proposed micro brewery have a petition of seven other residents who say they support the effort. That pretty much accounts for the 11 occupied homes along the two-and-a-half mile stretch of road.

Thomas Farm Road resident Jean Lacoste broke down and cried, saying the brewery right across the road from their home is destroying the life they hoped to make on Thomas Farm Road. Her husband, Paul, second-guessed county officials who approved the operation and suggested the brewery owners didn’t have the proper permits to operate the facility. Others talked about traffic "doubling" on the road. The owners estimate about 10 visitors a day on the four days a week (Thursday through Sunday) when they plan to be open. A Virginia Department of Transportation study found about 15 vehicles a day travel the road now and that includes cars, FedEx/UPI delivery van and logging trucks.

Brett Nichols, one of the four owners of the proposed operation, calls Shooting Creek Farm Brewery a "small, family-run operation." Nichols is already operating an organic farm at the location and says he feels the operation will increase the property values of the owners, who also live on Thomas Farm Road. Opponents disagree, saying the brewery will dump their property values into the crapper.

We don’t have a brewery in our neighborhood. The folks who own the farm across Sandy Flats Road from our property own race cars and sometimes tune them late into the night. Their kids own dirt bikes and like to race up and down the hills of the farm. Sometimes the race cars and dirt bikes are loud but it’s their property and the Floyd County way is to let people make their own decision about how to use their land.

Hearing officer Robert O’Neal said he will deliver an opinion on the license for the brewery in 30-45 days but the neighborhood feud is not likely to end with that decision. The losing side can appeal for a rehearing before the state board officers in Richmond, a process that will extend the fight for two-to-three months more. Then whichever size loses can appeal again for a hearing before Judge Ray W. Grubbs in Floyd County Circuit Court — which means the fight will drag on until next year.

But O’Neal put the whole battle into perspective when he asked Nichols how much beer his operation would brew in a year. The answer: About 600 barrels.  About half of that will go into kegs to wholesale distribution to bars and restaurants in and around Floyd County. The other half will be bottled and packed into 360 cases.

O’Neal wanted to know how much room it takes to store or ship 360 cases of beer. Nichols said it would take three 4×4 palletes (each pallete holds 80 cases).

O’Neal calculated the volume of both the cases and kegs and noted that the entire annual production of the proposed micro brewery would not fill half of a single trailor on a semi-truck.

"In other words, we’re not talking about Budweiser here," he said.

Nope. We’re not.

Share:

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn

6 Responses

  1. Let’s not forget that we have no zoning here, which we have always held to mean we can pursue our dreams and avocations on our property.

    To hold this standard with some properties but not others opens a can of worms. I believe all residents are entitled to earn their keep here. And I have had to swallow my comments when I’ve had others encroach on my standards of propriety as well.

    This only works in an atmosphere of tolerance. Which we seem to have misplaced.

    Any activity will have an impact, road race, rental property, brewery, farm, school, garage or church all require patience and forbearance on the part of neighbors, and respect on the part of the advocate.

    To bring these petty complaints the state authorities guarantees bad feelings.

  2. I found that in cases like these, you have to listen between the lines to ferret out the real reason people come out against a project. Many times it’s just NIMBY raising its ugly head, no matter what the excuse given as to why a project should be rejected. People may use the ‘alcohol is not what we want in a family environment’ excuse, or the ‘it will bring a bad crowd’ excuse because those are easier to sell. They will try anything to keep ‘their neighborhood’ exactly the way they are comfortable with it.

  3. Unless you are willing to live in complete isolation, it’s not reasonable to expect that your neighborhood is going to remain frozen in time forever. We’re talking about a business that is going to have about the same traffic impact as a kid with a lemonade stand. I wasn’t able to attend the hearing, but I wrote a brief article on my site today if you’re interested.

Comments are closed.

On Key
Related Posts
Keeping time around the world

Keeping time around the world

In a period of my adult, professional, life, I spent many days (and nights) on planes flying around the world. For many of those years,