The oppression of forced religious belief

Bonnie Erbe, an excellant columnist whose work appears often on one of my news web sites, filed an interesting piece this week on a religious harassment case involving Blacksburg Middle School.

Writes Erbe:

Judith Scott probably never set out to be a First Amendment heroine. But she is as far as I'm concerned. Scott has filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Virginia for what she claims was a retaliatory firing. Her proselytizing boss at the Blacksburg, Va. Middle School, whose acts are detailed in her court filing, kept trying to force her to participate in unlawful prayer meetings and religious events at work.

I learned about Scott in the Collegiate Times, the campus newspaper of Virginia Tech. Driving to Blacksburg from Washington, D.C., one passes signs for Christendom College and other reminders that one is traversing Bible country. Small towns dot the angled landscape of the Blue Ridge Mountains.

The Times reports that Scott was asked by her supervisor whether an unnamed person could "pray for her" and she complied out of a sense of pressure. She later declined to attend a religious conference with faculty members and was deluged by them with Christian-themed DVDs and audiotapes upon their return.

"The suit alleges that the supervisor would dim the library's lights, hold prayer meetings, 'anoint' the premises and 'lay hands' on those present. The supervisor would also leave 'praise' sticky notes and daily Bible verses around for Scott to see."

The Times goes on to describe the pressure put on Scott to practice Christianity in what became a hostile work environment. It never explains whether Scott is a non-believer or a believer of a different faith. But she clearly put up with a huge amount of religious harassment before she filed her lawsuit.

She took her case first to the assistant school board superintendent and was offered a transfer to another facility. But she stood her ground and said she wanted to continue working as a media aid assistant right where she was, as she had done nothing wrong. That takes guts! When her contract ended it was not renewed. She claimed she was in essence, fired, in retaliation for her complaints.

I'm not surprised Scott came under attack by religious zealots. Whenever I dare write something that suggests a minister or religious fanatic has overstepped their bounds my email box fills with messages of hate in the name of God and I often find religious material slid under the door of my studio.

It does surprise me, however, that this happened in Blacksburg, home of a giant state university and a community supposedly more enlightened when it comes to the First Amendment and religious freedom.

Our founding fathers had the right idea when it came to separation of church and state. Everyone has a right to believe or not believe in a supreme being. Everyone has a right to practice or not practice religion. No one has a right to force their religious beliefs on others.

We often find religious material on our doorstep, left by those who see themselves as traveling salesmen for God. A black hearse often cruises the streets of Floyd, covered with signs warning us that doomsday is coming and urging us to get right with the Lord. Local ministers use the power of their pulpit to stop the Commonwealth from opening an ABC store in Floyd or to attempt to stop a microbrewery from opening.

At least one of our supervisors demands to know where candidates from office stand on requiring prayer in schools. He thinks it should be mandated.

Erbe writes:

President Bush's eight-year tenure, in which religion formed and mis-formed federal laws, trumped science in federal policy and even may have been partly responsible for launching an unsuccessful war, allowed situations such as Scott's to flourish throughout the land. This is hardly the only way in which the Bush presidency took us back 50 years. It is, however, a dominant theme of his tenure as is the takeover of the Republican Party by the religious right.

Judith Scott is hardly alone. One need only peruse the Web sites of Americans United for Separation of Church and State (au.org) or the Freedom From Religion Foundation (ffrf.org) to find documentation of countless instances of religious discrimination perpetrated, even encouraged, during the Bush years. Americans United has a nine-point agenda it is asking Obama to follow. The group is asking him to ban faith-based job bias (as faced by Scott), restrict faith-based funding and end school vouchers (which are nothing but a federal bonanza for Christian and religious schools.)

Religion is a personal matter. So is an individual's relationship with God or whatever supreme being he or she may or may not accept.

A few years ago, a young man with religious sayings pinned to his clothing became a familiar sight in downtown Floyd. He approached me on day and, in a loud voice, asked: "Have you found God?"

I looked at him in shock: "Lord no! Is he missing?"

No, God isn't missing. He's just waiting for us at home.

Bonnie Erbe, an excellant columnist whose work appears often on one of my news web sites, filed an interesting piece this week on a religious harassment case involving Blacksburg Middle School.

Writes Erbe:

Judith Scott probably never set out to be a First Amendment heroine. But she is as far as I’m concerned. Scott has filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Virginia for what she claims was a retaliatory firing. Her proselytizing boss at the Blacksburg, Va. Middle School, whose acts are detailed in her court filing, kept trying to force her to participate in unlawful prayer meetings and religious events at work.

I learned about Scott in the Collegiate Times, the campus newspaper of Virginia Tech. Driving to Blacksburg from Washington, D.C., one passes signs for Christendom College and other reminders that one is traversing Bible country. Small towns dot the angled landscape of the Blue Ridge Mountains.

The Times reports that Scott was asked by her supervisor whether an unnamed person could "pray for her" and she complied out of a sense of pressure. She later declined to attend a religious conference with faculty members and was deluged by them with Christian-themed DVDs and audiotapes upon their return.

"The suit alleges that the supervisor would dim the library’s lights, hold prayer meetings, ‘anoint’ the premises and ‘lay hands’ on those present. The supervisor would also leave ‘praise’ sticky notes and daily Bible verses around for Scott to see."

The Times goes on to describe the pressure put on Scott to practice Christianity in what became a hostile work environment. It never explains whether Scott is a non-believer or a believer of a different faith. But she clearly put up with a huge amount of religious harassment before she filed her lawsuit.

She took her case first to the assistant school board superintendent and was offered a transfer to another facility. But she stood her ground and said she wanted to continue working as a media aid assistant right where she was, as she had done nothing wrong. That takes guts! When her contract ended it was not renewed. She claimed she was in essence, fired, in retaliation for her complaints.

I’m not surprised Scott came under attack by religious zealots. Whenever I dare write something that suggests a minister or religious fanatic has overstepped their bounds my email box fills with messages of hate in the name of God and I often find religious material slid under the door of my studio.

It does surprise me, however, that this happened in Blacksburg, home of a giant state university and a community supposedly more enlightened when it comes to the First Amendment and religious freedom.

Our founding fathers had the right idea when it came to separation of church and state. Everyone has a right to believe or not believe in a supreme being. Everyone has a right to practice or not practice religion. No one has a right to force their religious beliefs on others.

We often find religious material on our doorstep, left by those who see themselves as traveling salesmen for God. A black hearse often cruises the streets of Floyd, covered with signs warning us that doomsday is coming and urging us to get right with the Lord. Local ministers use the power of their pulpit to stop the Commonwealth from opening an ABC store in Floyd or to attempt to stop a microbrewery from opening.

At least one of our supervisors demands to know where candidates from office stand on requiring prayer in schools. He thinks it should be mandated.

Erbe writes:

President Bush’s eight-year tenure, in which religion formed and mis-formed federal laws, trumped science in federal policy and even may have been partly responsible for launching an unsuccessful war, allowed situations such as Scott’s to flourish throughout the land. This is hardly the only way in which the Bush presidency took us back 50 years. It is, however, a dominant theme of his tenure as is the takeover of the Republican Party by the religious right.

Judith Scott is hardly alone. One need only peruse the Web sites of Americans United for Separation of Church and State (au.org) or the Freedom From Religion Foundation (ffrf.org) to find documentation of countless instances of religious discrimination perpetrated, even encouraged, during the Bush years. Americans United has a nine-point agenda it is asking Obama to follow. The group is asking him to ban faith-based job bias (as faced by Scott), restrict faith-based funding and end school vouchers (which are nothing but a federal bonanza for Christian and religious schools.)

Religion is a personal matter. So is an individual’s relationship with God or whatever supreme being he or she may or may not accept.

A few years ago, a young man with religious sayings pinned to his clothing became a familiar sight in downtown Floyd. He approached me on day and, in a loud voice, asked: "Have you found God?"

I looked at him in shock: "Lord no! Is he missing?"

No, God isn’t missing. He’s just waiting for us at home.

Share:

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn

14 Responses

  1. No, no one should be ‘forced’ into any type of hostile environment at work.

    Just out of curiosity, but did anyone else report the same thing or see anyone ‘anointing’ the premises? Is it possible this was made up because she wasnt very good at plugging in headphones or checking in video tapes?

    Im not calling her a liar in any way at all. I never read the article or the filings but it seems sketchy that a supervisor in an ‘enlightened’ community like Blacksburg would force religion on anyone to this extreme and NOT expect to get reprimanded immediately. There are a LOT of teachers/staff at Blacksburg Middle school and certainly others would have ‘witnessed’ these acts also?

  2. it seems that too many Christians feel that their beliefs entitle them look down on others who view the universe differently….forcing Christianity down people’s throats has been happening since, well, the dawn of Christianity.

    Christian teachings aside…if we look to history, being forced to sit through a few seances and/or getting greased ‘n groped by a self-proclaimed man of God is small potatoes when you look what they did to any (and every!) indigenous group they’ve encountered in the quest to win souls.

  3. How can you tell if someone has been born again?

    They’ll have two bellybuttons.

    Everyone else is just talking.

  4. Like I said earlier… it would be nice to know if this actually happened or not, but doesnt anyone find it a little sketchy as to why the Collegiate Times was the ‘breaking news’ on this story? The Collegiate Times is a fine, basically limited to campus, free publication and all but I would certainly think that if the Roanoke Times had the chance to rip apart A) anything which makes Blacksburg look bad B) anything that has to do with religious persecution C) something that THEY actually thought was true as well, then the RT would have been on this long ago.

    Im afraid that there is at least as good of a chance that the lady was unfairly hammered with religious bias at work as the possibility that she was let go because of not being a very good library-aid-media-assistant and nothing to do with religion.

Comments are closed.

On Key
Related Posts
Keeping time around the world

Keeping time around the world

In a period of my adult, professional, life, I spent many days (and nights) on planes flying around the world. For many of those years,